Kravius Pila wrote:^ Why "oviously" a cover couln'd be as good as the original ...? Simply, these voise are a different style...
I said "more pleasant", but it's true, Riho progress more and more, and Sakura is a jewel. =3
Okay, listen. Please understand that there's a huge difference between the performance of a song by the original group and a shuffle performance. MM。have had
months to sharpen their Help me!! performances even before they started performing in public. S/mileage and J=J only had concert rehearsals. It's not the same as doing a recording where you go over the nuances of the song, it's not the same as shooting a PV/dance shot where you do the dance again and again until it's absolutely perfect and it's definitely not the same as TV performances.
Obviously it's not going to be as good. But why even bother being so critical? It's perfectly fine. Shuffle performances like these are made to be entertaining. Yes, they're still good. But just because it's not completely, 100% perfect doesn't mean they're bad.
The performance was fine and I honestly don't see the need to compare. I get why people are, but these girls put in a lot of work and then people shit on them like "It's not the original it sucks". That's not the point. That's not fair.
I'm going to assume English isn't your first language, so forgive me for being harsh, but I'm more addressing this to everyone. The way you worded your post sounded unnecessarily mean, even if you weren't trying to be.
Parhelion69 wrote:^ Meimi doing Riho's line wasn't as good either.
Also, Sayube wasn't as good as Sakura.
And Takechan also fell flat with her line.
And the unison parts weren't as good.
And I could nit-pick even further.
And nobody gives a fuck.
Do people not realise how hard MM。's songs are nowadays? Jesus, y'all are far too harsh and need to learn how to enjoy things without criticising every aspect.