JPLOP.COM

Denki wrote:Yeah... Tsubaki's cover is like 100x better than the original. Lol The ED has a very J-pop/idol feel.

This.

The thing that really killed the original version was the vocals. Just shit.

Kind of reminds me of what happened with a song called Hawaiian Roller Coaster from the original Lilo & Stitch movie. The song in the film sounded really good with mature Hawaiian vocals, but the single version was some shit with teen vocals. Arhgh.

Each country has its style. X) You don't like this version, no problem.
But even if Tsubaki 's vocal is lacking about high notes, is high pitched, it's interesting to see a h! p unit challenging a non hp concept, nice for growing up and working about themself you know...
( and I prefer this version, the original version is too much powerful and, for me, it kills the atmosphere)

Tsubaki 's vocal is lacking about high notes,

Did we listen to the same song? There was a lot of adlibs and high notes.

That is not what I said. Sorry for the misunderstanding, but I wanted to say that Tsubaki has some difficulties with high notes.

There are high notes indeed but Tsubaki struggled with those. Well, to be fair Tsubaki is H!P’s weakest vocal group, but they’re actually good considering idol standards.

Today Tsubaki Factory made a visit to Taito Ward Higashiizumi Elementary School for a Trolls event and sing for 100 kids and Trolls characters Poppy and Branch to unveil the new ending song. Then they got to collab and dance with the kids.

Trolls event reports and lots of pics

Tsubaki Factory appeared on the decorated Trolls stage in the gymnasium and lots of cheers. Yamagishi says she is happy to sing and dance at the elementary school. The members love the hugging choreography. The kids said they were really excited to learn the dance. Another kid said, to dance with a celebrity like this will be a lasting memory for the rest his life.






https://www.movie-news.jp/trolls/2018/09/27/event/
https://eiga.com/news/20180927/17/
https://www.tokyo-sports.co.jp/entame/e ... t/1138900/
https://www.nikkansports.com/entertainm ... 00725.html
https://twitter.com/TVTOKYO_PR/status/1 ... 6088444928

videos :

Tsubaki Factory entrance

tweet

Ono Mizuho also got an early birthday surprise

tweet

https://twitter.com/Trolls_jp



https://twitter.com/Trolls_jp/status/10 ... 1760834560

Event off-shot : in a classroom getting ready for the event


https://twitter.com/Trolls_jp/status/10 ... 7736648705












http://ameblo.jp/tsubaki-factory/entry-12407997173.html

MV off-shot

To me, having a really good quality voice in and of itself really means nothing. I've heard many singer with technically great voices, that I just can't stand to listen to for very long. Either from not having an actual half decent song, just never ending wailing, or anything in between.

Tsubaki might not have the strongest voices, but to me, they're more then good enough to make the song heaps more enjoyable than the original.
They're still learning, like all Idols, and they'll gradually get better.

Great job by these lovely Trollkahashi successors!

Yattaruchan wrote:To me, having a really good quality voice in and of itself really means nothing. I've heard many singer with technically great voices, that I just can't stand to listen to for very long. Either from not having an actual half decent song, just never ending wailing, or anything in between.

Tsubaki might not have the strongest voices, but to me, they're more then good enough to make the song heaps more enjoyable than the original.
They're still learning, like all Idols, and they'll gradually get better.

Yeah I agree.
I didn't understand the "killed the original version" ... (in France it's not really the same meaning so...)

Kravius Pila wrote:I didn't understand the "killed the original version" ... (in France it's not really the same meaning so...)

Musically (without the vocals), the original actually sounds fine to me. So, by "killed", I meant was that it was the original's vocals that totally stopped it from being any good to listen to. It's a fairly common phrase in English.